NBC’s Katy Tur Not Sold on ‘Strict Originalist View of Constitution’ Because it’s 2018

Paul Morigi/Getty Images for Fortune

NBC News’ Katy Tur on Wednesday questioned whether the Supreme Court should take an originalist view of the Constitution — because we are living in the current year.

A partial transcript follows:

TUR: I do want to start with you, J.D. Based on where Americans stand on the issues, and Americans have really moved in a much more progressive direction over the years, do you think it’s appropriate to continue to take such a strict originalist view of the Constitution given it’s 2018 and not 1776? [The Constitution was written in 1787.]

VANCE: Well, I don’t know that Americans have become more Progressive on everything. Certainly, times have changed since 1776, but how you interpret the Constitution is ultimately different from what policy preferences you want.

This is a point conservatives make pretty often about the Supreme Court. Whether you want the laws to move in a progressive or conservative direction, the Supreme Court is a separate institution with a separate mandate under our constitutional structures.

For example, if you want abortion to be outlawed or you want abortion not to be outlawed, that is a question, and there’s an open debate around whether that question should be decided by the Supreme Court or that question should be decided by voters and state legislatures, and by federal legislators. That is a question to me about constitutional structure, not so much about policy preferences. Continue reading at breitbart.com.

Click on this link for more about our Founders

2 responses to “NBC’s Katy Tur Not Sold on ‘Strict Originalist View of Constitution’ Because it’s 2018”

  1. Joe Z says:

    Hey Katy, A strict, originalist view of the Constitution is what makes it the law of the land. Too many liberals, including liberal judges and lawyers, act like it’s their job to wet their fingers, stick them in the air and tell the rest of us what the Constitution means this week. Wrong!

  2. ,The Flash says:

    Sure Katy, things like freedom of speech, assembly, etc, along with things like illegal search & seizure certainly change with time and progress! Yeah, right! Here’s some advice for you, relax your sphincter and remove your head!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *